DSCC News

Chatham Rise mining could have impacts on whales, dolphins, EPA told

21 October 2014

Mining phosphate on the Chatham Rise, on New Zealand’s continental shelf, could potentially have many impacts on marine mammals like whales and dolphins, the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) was told today.

Whale expert, University of Otago’s Associate Professor Liz Slooten, gave evidence on behalf of Greenpeace, Kiwis Against Seabed Mining (KASM), and the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition (DSCC) at the EPA’s hearing into the Chatham Rock Phosphate Ltd (CRP) application for seabed mining in 450 metre deep waters to mine phosphates on the Chatham Rise entered its fifth week.

Professor Slooten told the EPA there were many potential impacts on marine mammals, including permanent or temporary hearing impairment, behavioral response, compromised ability to communicate and orient, including to hunt for prey, potential direct impacts on marine mammals that may come into contact with the plume of sediment from the mining and pollution from uranium.

Despite these potential threats, the company had carried out no visual or acoustic surveys to establish what whales were in the vicinity, and there was no empirical data on noise that would be generated by the mining.   Instead, CRP contractors had constructed a model extrapolating noise from a shallow-water mining operation, a model that, for example, did not take into account noise from pipes taking sediment 450 metres up to the ship - or back down.

“There are a number of potentially serious impacts on marine mammals.  More rigorous environmental impact assessment would be needed to assess the severity of the impacts of this development,” said Slooten.

Marine mammal species known to use the Chatham rise area include blue whales, bottlenose dolphins, common dolphins, dusky dolphins, false killer whales, humpback whales, killer whales, minke whales, pilot whales, sei whales, southern right whales, sperm whales and NZ fur seals, plus the species group beaked whales, according to Slooten. 

However, there was also a need to understand the number of any of these marine mammals in this area, which simply hadn’t been studied properly.

“From a scientific point of view, three years of baseline monitoring is the minimum required to collect baseline data on distribution and abundance of marine mammals and this is also the minimum to provide a realistic chance of detecting effects on other species,” she said.

None of this work had been done by the company.

 

Note to editors:

Chatham Rock Phosphate Ltd has applied to New Zealand’s Environmental Protection Authority for a marine consent to carry out seabed mining on the Chatham Rise, between New Zealand’s South Islands and the Chatham Islands, in waters about 450 metres deep. The application is heard by a 5 member Decision-Making Committee. All documents are on the EPA website at http://www.epa.govt.nz/EEZ/chatham_rock_phosphate/Pages/default.aspx.

The hearing will take nine weeks and is expected to conclude on 20 November. A decision is expected by late December.

Greenpeace, the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition and Kiwis Against Seabed Mining (KASM) have formed a coalition to oppose the application. The coalition has called evidence on benthic (seafloor life) effects (Prof. Les Watling from the University of Hawaii), marine mammals (Assoc. Prof. Liz Slooten from the University of Otago), toxic effects (Assoc. Prof. Barrie Peake from the University of Otago) and regulation of radiation (Dr David Santillo), since the phosphate to be mined has a high proportion of uranium.